Theoben Rapid Forum

Theoben General Chat Area => Theoben Rapid Discussion => Topic started by: GB2017 on July 10, 2020, 03:49:26 PM

Title: Recommended barrels....
Post by: GB2017 on July 10, 2020, 03:49:26 PM
Ok one of the first (of many) noob questions in my quest for knowledge.....

Sooo what are the common barrels employed when re-barrelling Rapids ie changing their calibre and then after what is common what are deemed to be the really good barrels out of that selection, specifically I am looking at 177

thanks
Title: Re: Recommended barrels....
Post by: KCE on July 10, 2020, 03:56:04 PM
Hi Geoff.
It is well known that rapid barrels can be pellet fussy you will find out in time.
If you are wanting new then I would suggest looking at https://www.silco.co.uk/barrel-blanks-17-c.asp
These have stood the test of time.
I was very fortunate 2 years ago when I bought a 19inch screw cut 22 of ebay for my project.
It has stood the test of time and this year I will upload a video of a rabbit shot at 200yds with my fac rapid with that barrel.
The length also comes into account when building your project 16inch is the most common but I would always go for screw cut for suppressor over than slip on.
Regards Kev.
Title: Re: Recommended barrels....
Post by: nevadacowboy on July 10, 2020, 04:18:04 PM
Sorry to hijack this post but I am also interested in this.  Is it better to go for a choked or unchoked barrel.
Title: Re: Recommended barrels....
Post by: KCE on July 10, 2020, 04:21:56 PM
It depends on person to person and what they want to achieve from there out fit.
there are pros and cons on both of them.
I like chocked barrels but I know of a new project that was built not to long ago I was there for that build at KevG and that was a un chocked polygon barrel in .25 doing 60ft.
I'm sure there will be more members who will also give you both advice on this matter.
Regards kev.
Title: Re: Recommended barrels....
Post by: GB2017 on July 10, 2020, 04:26:31 PM
Quote from: KCE on July 10, 2020, 03:56:04 PM
Hi Geoff.
It is well known that rapid barrels can be pellet fussy you will find out in time.
If you are wanting new then I would suggest looking at https://www.silco.co.uk/barrel-blanks-17-c.asp
These have stood the test of time.
I was very fortunate 2 years ago when I bought a 19inch screw cut 22 of ebay for my project.
It has stood the test of time and this year I will upload a video of a rabbit shot at 200yds with my fac rapid with that barrel.
The length also comes into account when building your project 16inch is the most common but I would always go for screw cut for suppressor over than slip on.
Regards Kev.

Hi Kev

Interesting that the Silco are Weihrauchs I must admit that I have sort of anticipated LW / Anschutzs being recommended.

Must admit my preference would be screw cut rather than slip on, have that with my s410 royal pita if you ask me

When I get my gun it will be sub 12 177.

@Nevadacowboy no need to apologise sir, perfectly acceptable question and as we are going to get here eventually what about the polygonal barrels too just to complicate stuff further
Title: Re: Recommended barrels....
Post by: GB2017 on July 10, 2020, 04:29:18 PM
Quote from: KCE on July 10, 2020, 04:21:56 PM
It depends on person to person and what they want to achieve from there out fit.
there are pros and cons on both of them.
I like chocked barrels but I know of a new project that was built not to long ago I was there for that build at KevG and that was a un chocked polygon barrel in .25 doing 60ft.
I'm sure there will be more members who will also give you both advice on this matter.
Regards kev.

So what are the positives / negatives of choked vs unchoked barrels?

Get as technical as you like just sort of aim at a retarded zombie marmoset language wise and you might just hit it ;-)
Title: Re: Recommended barrels....
Post by: KCE on July 10, 2020, 04:30:19 PM
Air Arms have also just introduced a new type of barrel they call stx.
most Theoben rapids came with a loather walther barrel chocked and some came with the anni barrels which are hard to find.
Some members use the BSA barrels also on there rapids.
Regards kev.
Title: Re: Recommended barrels....
Post by: KCE on July 10, 2020, 04:35:15 PM
This may help you.
Regards kev.
Title: Re: Recommended barrels....
Post by: KCE on July 10, 2020, 04:38:59 PM
I'm sure that at sub 12 chocked barrels will work much better.
Unchoked at times can work better but only at FAC.
Regards kev.
Title: Re: Recommended barrels....
Post by: GB2017 on July 10, 2020, 04:48:52 PM
Quote from: KCE on July 10, 2020, 04:35:15 PM
This may help you.
Regards kev.

Helps a lot many thanks Sir!!!
Title: Re: Recommended barrels....
Post by: Ca_Varminter on July 10, 2020, 04:50:27 PM
Quote from: GB2017 on July 10, 2020, 04:29:18 PM

So what are the positives / negatives of choked vs unchoked barrels?

That is an Age old Question......
I run my Titanium Rapid @60+ fpe
LW Polygonal barrel unchoked..

The purpose of the choke was to make that barrel less pellet fussy..
Well it seems to do the opposite if you have a Very Tight Choke...
Also it seems to affect the larger Cal. more...
But that is my Personal experience...
You ask a room full of airgunners...You will have a broad spectrum of opinions!!

Stuart
Title: Re: Recommended barrels....
Post by: KevG on July 10, 2020, 06:09:22 PM
done loads of silco barrels and all have been great apart from one.i like unchoked my self.but each to their own..you can get good and bad in all the brands.
KevG
Title: Re: Recommended barrels....
Post by: Squinty on July 11, 2020, 11:01:25 AM
I've had two unchoked LWs on my FAC ,  both of them have been pellet fussy.
The original LW was massively over choked and I've simply gone from one end of the scale to the other. Hard lead 5.50s to struggling with finding consistent batches of 5.53s.

I put a 177 HW100 factory finished barrel on my sub12 mk2, seems to be fairly good.
Bought that from SWS and Kev trimmed it, shaved a whisker off the breech end and ported it.
The Euro exchange rate was better and it cost £109 posted for a full length blued and screw-cut barrel.

I've got another HW100 tube in 22 for Kev to fettle when he's not so busy.
This one stands me at £122 but it's still cheaper than another LW blank.
Title: Re: Recommended barrels....
Post by: GB2017 on July 12, 2020, 07:23:46 AM
Well this has been a real eye opener, I had expected to be deluged with recommendations for LW / Annie. I had a LW in my Leshiy and did like them, so that's given me cause to pause and recontemplate
Title: Re: Recommended barrels....
Post by: daystatesniper on July 12, 2020, 07:33:40 AM
The thing is Annie barrels are usually great so owners keep them ,and when they do come up for sale they can fetch the kind of prices that would bail a third world country out of debt !!

atvb' Mick
Title: Re: Recommended barrels....
Post by: GB2017 on July 12, 2020, 09:08:49 AM
Quote from: daystatesniper on July 12, 2020, 07:33:40 AM
The thing is Annie barrels are usually great so owners keep them ,and when they do come up for sale they can fetch the kind of prices that would bail a third world country out of debt !!

atvb' Mick

so is it a specific annie barrel or any?
Title: Re: Recommended barrels....
Post by: KevG on July 12, 2020, 11:11:48 AM
the problem with some of the anschutz barrells is they can be over choked.its theoben who did the choking.
KevG
Title: Re: Recommended barrels....
Post by: Squinty on July 12, 2020, 12:15:41 PM
Another one to throw in the equation  BSA, but at 15.5mm they need the breech end sleeving.
They were very good and 15 odd years ago considered the THE replacement / upgrade for a fussy TB barrel.
Believe Chambers still have some  177 blanks, but tbh...BSA went through a period of shockingly s**** production and QC.

From what I've gleaned some HW barrels were actually made by LW with a faster twist rate, also springer and PCP barrels also had different twists... depending on the application.

Also the option of a CZ barrel, believe the AA S200  more machining work but expensive and RFD delivery only



Title: Re: Recommended barrels....
Post by: KevG on July 12, 2020, 03:30:18 PM
I have one of the old BSA barrels Steve m8 in .22.had for around 25 years now.its been on 4 different rapids.would never part with it.this one is unchoked.when I first got it I roded a pellet through and was a bit gutted as it felt so slopy and loose and pellet just ploped out of the barrel.i realy thought I had a bad one.but this thing is a tack driver.
KevG
Title: Re: Recommended barrels....
Post by: Squinty on July 12, 2020, 05:45:02 PM
My father put one on the FAC Rapid, 2005-6ish plus a long AWT mod but for reasons unknown that came barrel off and was replaced with the original uber-choke LW.

Title: Re: Recommended barrels....
Post by: GB2017 on July 16, 2020, 02:28:42 PM
is it safe for me to assume that we are talking about 16mm diameter silco / weihrauch barrels?
Title: Re: Recommended barrels....
Post by: KevG on July 16, 2020, 10:06:16 PM
yes m8.
KevG
Title: Re: Recommended barrels....
Post by: GB2017 on July 17, 2020, 09:12:24 AM
thanks will get ordering

next daft question what needs to be done to the barrel when I get it as I know it isnt going to be wack it with a club hammer and its fitted lol
Title: Re: Recommended barrels....
Post by: rgc_swanseaARC on July 17, 2020, 10:30:16 AM
I am on my third barrel on my TTR.

The original 19 inch one was just pointless so i got rid.
I replaced with another unknown rapid original barrel and it shot well but only with bis mags / baracuda match.
The third one i had custom made by Impact Airguns at the time when they were still going.  14 inch, LW barrel in the white.
They cut it, ported, hand crimped a bit at a time tested and then finally added the screwcut.  I told them i wanted it to shoot Exact Express and they engineered it to do so.  It is unbelievable!
I also tried a HW barrel blank and had this machined to fit, but it turned out that the bore was all over the place and not concentric so this was again binned.

If it were me, i would be looking at either an unchoked LW and have it engineered to fit, or second to that a 16mm CZ barrel from an AA MPR or S200, these can also be incredibly accurate.

Nick had great success with an old Falcon barrel but this would need to be sleeved to make it fit, but again seemed very accurate.

Regards,
Rhys
Title: Re: Recommended barrels....
Post by: GB2017 on July 17, 2020, 10:55:40 AM
Quote from: rgc_swanseaARC on July 17, 2020, 10:30:16 AM
I am on my third barrel on my TTR.

The original 19 inch one was just pointless so i got rid.
I replaced with another unknown rapid original barrel and it shot well but only with bis mags / baracuda match.
The third one i had custom made by Impact Airguns at the time when they were still going.  14 inch, LW barrel in the white.
They cut it, ported, hand crimped a bit at a time tested and then finally added the screwcut.  I told them i wanted it to shoot Exact Express and they engineered it to do so.  It is unbelievable!
I also tried a HW barrel blank and had this machined to fit, but it turned out that the bore was all over the place and not concentric so this was again binned.

If it were me, i would be looking at either an unchoked LW and have it engineered to fit, or second to that a 16mm CZ barrel from an AA MPR or S200, these can also be incredibly accurate.

Nick had great success with an old Falcon barrel but this would need to be sleeved to make it fit, but again seemed very accurate.

Regards,
Rhys

Thanks Rhys, interesting read

I need to get a .20 barrel and i am not sure whether cz make these for the s200, don't think so but will have to look, so probably leaves me with the lw / silco offering
Title: Re: Recommended barrels....
Post by: GB2017 on July 17, 2020, 02:38:34 PM
out of curiosity, anyone ever tried a leshiy barrel?

I know from experience they are very accurate lw barrels, probably would need sleeving to fit

just a thought.....