Hi all, I started a thread the other day as my groupings at 50 yards was garbage! Cut a long story shortish, I removed my cf bottle and put my 400cc alloy bottle back on did some targets in the garden at 20yards and they was hitting pellet on pellet at the first mill dot above the centre cross, however when I took the the field at 50 yards and took a shot it landed where the blue dot is on the target I'm going to attach.
So I moved it roughly 8 clicks to the right and took some more shots and got this grouping with 10 shots (2nd picture) . So I moved it back left one click and left it at that!
When I got back home I thought my gun isn't going to be zeros for the 20 yards like before but when I shot at the target in the garden it was still putting pellet on pellet (3rd picture) this really confused me I can't understand why my zero is still bang on at 20 yards after moving my copes 8 clicks right!!
Can someone explain the reason to this just so I can understand it and learn from this
Thanks
What size are the targets, is the scope moa or mrad, what mag were they taken at, is the scope SFP or FFP ?
I'll assume 14cm square targets with a 10mm bull & 5mm rings, in which case your group is around 55mm right of the blue dot.
Most airgun scopes are MOA 1/4" so 1 click is 1/4" at 100yds, therefore at 50yds 1 click is 1/8" so your 8 clicks would move POI by 1" ,
55mm is about 2.2" so those figures do not equate ???
If the scope is MRAD 1 click is 10mm at 100m, 5mm at 50m so 8 clicks is 40mm at 50m, 50yds is 45.7m so 8 clicks would be 38mm ish, again the figures do not equate.
There could be backlash in the scope mech so the first click back doesn't actually move anything, but that makes matters worse :o
But the best explanation is that for the blue dot shot, your body position was not settled and your eye was simply not correctly aligned, what was the shooting position?
At 20yds in your garden 1/4" at 100yds equals 1/20" so your adjustment would be 7/20" or 9mm in MRAD.
In your garden you probably have a more comfortable & steady shooting position, & the 20yds is probably where you set the ocular so the scope focus is perfect,
Do you shoot wearing the same jacket and from the same position, prone/sitting/standing ? it all makes fractional differences to the POI.
I have to add that having seen a pic your bipod appears very, very low,
I could certainly not shoot that rifle prone off such a low bipod, & I suspect your shooting position has a lot to do with it.
Hope that might be of some help.
Almost forgot, SFP - FFP
Because the ret is fixed in SFP if you reduce the mag to shoot at close range a small target like the dot you used at 20yds, can get hidden behind the cross of the ret,
if you then shoot when you see a bit of the dot edge out from behind the cross, you're not actually centred on it & your POA is inconsistent.
FFP the ret shrinks/expands along with the mag so on a small target at low mag, you can see the exact centre & your POA can be much more consistent.
Have you tried another Scope?
Have try switching your ring: back to front, front to back....
If you are using a rail, check the screws are tight....
Good Luck,
Stuart
Hi angry bear, I'm still new to shooting and learning stuff everyday, I didn't think it was that complicated and went that deep I just see it as moving the poi with the clickers and I keep moving till it hits bull, however I have noticed my shooting position isn't the best and I don't feel comfortable when shooting.
I don't have a clue what you mean by SFP, FFP. Could you please explain. The scope is moa I do know that.
I've just been watching a video and a guy we're explaining that when you zoom in your poi changes slightly is that right?
It's all a case of learning and putting it to use really mate any information I can get is helpful and much appreciated!!
Quote from: smithy123 on June 21, 2022, 03:57:30 PM
Hi angry bear, I'm still new to shooting and learning stuff everyday, I didn't think it was that complicated and went that deep I just see it as moving the poi with the clickers and I keep moving till it hits bull, however I have noticed my shooting position isn't the best and I don't feel comfortable when shooting.
I don't have a clue what you mean by SFP, FFP. Could you please explain. The scope is moa I do know that.
I've just been watching a video and a guy we're explaining that when you zoom in your poi changes slightly is that right?
It's all a case of learning and putting it to use really mate any information I can get is helpful and much appreciated!!
First focal plane ... second focal plane ..
when you adjust your magnification does the reticule stay the same or does it increase in size as you up the magnification
most scopes are second .. and you would defently no if it was first
Quote from: smithy123 on June 21, 2022, 03:57:30 PM
I don't have a clue what you mean by SFP, FFP. Could you please explain. The scope is moa I do know that.
SFP and FFP refers to where the scope's crosshairs are located with in the scope's visual system
In a SFP, 2nd Focal Plane, most common... as you zoom in, the target gets larger and the crosshairs stay the same size.
But in a FFP. 1st Focal Plane scope, as you zoom in both the target AND crosshairs are magnified!!!
Quote from: smithy123 on June 21, 2022, 03:57:30 PM
I've just been watching a video and a guy we're explaining that when you zoom in your poi changes slightly is that right?
It all depends on the Construction and Quality of the Scope!!
Like my S&B PMII, it is rock solid as I zoom from 12 to 50x.....
Stuart
yes if you zero your scope let's say at 10x magnification.. all of your values changes if you go either up or down ..
I generally . dont mess with magnification I set zero at 10x mag.. then use the focus on the yardage im shooting at then it give you a rough estimate on range
Hi Stuart right I get you know mine is sfp I have seen the ffp ones so I'm going to look at a few is there any decent FFP scopes that are few decent price?
Reply for angry bear,
Hi mate I've just put the mag back to how I had it in in the garden shooting at 20 yards and it's shooting 10/15mm to the right, yesterday it was shooting fine at 20 yards max mag and it's mil dot under but for some reason that has now change there no wind I'm shooting in the same position, bottle is at the same bar. It's bang on line with the target just 10/15mm to the right??
It's leaving me pickled this🤨🤨
Just a thought check for clipping in the end of suppressor but I have a feeling it could be the clamp giving you probs or the mag.
Regards kev.
your not canting the gun are you.
KevG
Quote from: smithy123 on June 21, 2022, 07:35:09 PM
Reply for angry bear,
Hi mate I've just put the mag back to how I had it in in the garden shooting at 20 yards and it's shooting 10/15mm to the right, yesterday it was shooting fine at 20 yards max mag and it's mil dot under but for some reason that has now change there no wind I'm shooting in the same position, bottle is at the same bar. It's bang on line with the target just 10/15mm to the right??
It's leaving me pickled this🤨🤨
That sounds to me like your scope's shagged, but as Kev says it could be canting.
Starting from basics, make sure the scope is exactly vertical on top of the rifle, I find the easiest way is to rest the bottle with the rifle at arms length, eye up the block to be vertical then look up at the scope turrets,
You'll see instantly if they're off, if they are correct the fit.
To check the scope, if possible use a rest to eliminate human error, for a target you need a cross, not a dot, so that you can align the cross of the scope which eliminates any risk of canting,
If you have 2 crosses on a target sheet, on the first fire 3 shots at minimum mag tun up to max mag shoot 3 more, move to the second cross shoot max mag first then go down to min shoot again.
In an ideal world all the shots at each target cross will be in a single group & the two should look pretty much identical.
If the min & max are in 2 different groups then the ret moved with the mag change, & to me the scope's shagged.
With regard to FFP scopes, they do cost more, you aren't going to buy a 4-16x44 (or 50) FFP for under £300,
Lots of people don't like them or don't see the point, I do but it's personal choice.
How many bar are you filling your gun to. Could have a bad power curve like one of mine has
If the original fault was poor accuracy.. shot gunning, inexplicable flyers then maybe the bottle clamp was touching.
But if you're chasing adjustments and POI is changing at different ranges and magnification I'd agree with Angrybear.
I had an Airmax 8-24x with a wandering zero, POI changed depending on the magnification used when it was dialed in.
Did my head in before I finally threw in the towel and bought a new scope.
Quote from: KCE on June 21, 2022, 09:08:41 PM
Just a thought check for clipping in the end of suppressor but I have a feeling it could be the clamp giving you probs or the mag.
Regards kev.
Checked suppressor all looks fine and the magnification is the exact same as the other day everything is the same. Changing the mag only seems to effect the hold over and under, like let's say max zoom on 12 is 1 mil dot under at 20 yards, but if I got to 6 on the mag then it's half mil dot. So I think I kinda understand that but what I don't understand is how it can move 15mm to the right over night
Quote from: angrybear on June 21, 2022, 11:01:03 PM
Quote from: smithy123 on June 21, 2022, 07:35:09 PM
Reply for angry bear,
Hi mate I've just put the mag back to how I had it in in the garden shooting at 20 yards and it's shooting 10/15mm to the right, yesterday it was shooting fine at 20 yards max mag and it's mil dot under but for some reason that has now change there no wind I'm shooting in the same position, bottle is at the same bar. It's bang on line with the target just 10/15mm to the right??
It's leaving me pickled this🤨🤨
That sounds to me like your scope's shagged, but as Kev says it could be canting.
Starting from basics, make sure the scope is exactly vertical on top of the rifle, I find the easiest way is to rest the bottle with the rifle at arms length, eye up the block to be vertical then look up at the scope turrets,
You'll see instantly if they're off, if they are correct the fit.
To check the scope, if possible use a rest to eliminate human error, for a target you need a cross, not a dot, so that you can align the cross of the scope which eliminates any risk of canting,
If you have 2 crosses on a target sheet, on the first fire 3 shots at minimum mag tun up to max mag shoot 3 more, move to the second cross shoot max mag first then go down to min shoot again.
In an ideal world all the shots at each target cross will be in a single group & the two should look pretty much identical.
If the min & max are in 2 different groups then the ret moved with the mag change, & to me the scope's shagged.
With regard to FFP scopes, they do cost more, you aren't going to buy a 4-16x44 (or 50) FFP for under £300,
Lots of people don't like them or don't see the point, I do but it's personal choice.
Been watching a few videos on some scopes and I'm liking this type of scope and how you change the clickers depending on yardage of quarry, not just that, I like the side focus as mine now is at the front and when adjusting at night I block the it torch so I can't see if the picture is still blurry
Quote from: KevG on June 21, 2022, 09:10:05 PM
your not canting the gun are you.
KevG
What is canting Kev mate
Quote from: Therapidman on June 22, 2022, 03:55:39 AM
How many bar are you filling your gun to. Could have a bad power curve like one of mine has
I don't think it has anything to do with power curve mate as it's verry consistent to as to we're it's shooting it's just not on zero anymore
Quote from: Squinty on June 22, 2022, 07:46:42 AM
If the original fault was poor accuracy.. shot gunning, inexplicable flyers then maybe the bottle clamp was touching.
But if you're chasing adjustments and POI is changing at different ranges and magnification I'd agree with Angrybear.
My scope is a sfp so the poi does change depending on magnification, but I have figured that out
I had an Airmax 8-24x with a wandering zero, POI changed depending on the magnification used when it was dialed in.
Did my head in before I finally threw in the towel and bought a new scope.
Quote from: smithy123 on June 22, 2022, 10:47:36 AM
Quote from: Squinty on June 22, 2022, 07:46:42 AM
If the original fault was poor accuracy.. shot gunning, inexplicable flyers then maybe the bottle clamp was touching.
But if you're chasing adjustments and POI is changing at different ranges and magnification I'd agree with Angrybear.
My scope is a sfp so the poi does change depending on magnification, but I have figured that out
I had an Airmax 8-24x with a wandering zero, POI changed depending on the magnification used when it was dialed in.
Did my head in before I finally threw in the towel and bought a new scope.
So ...you didn't know that the scale of the reticle was only true at 10x and continued to make the same 20yd adjustments @ 3.5moa (14 clicks) per dot - but at 50yds and at 16-20-24x?
Acceptable error......over or under adjusting.
I can't get on with ranging SFP mildots and making mental adjustments , thinking in inch/moa then converting 3.5x @ 'X' times mag @ 'Y' range.
FFP with MOA turrets and reticle every time for me now.
Still not the reason why the windage is out 4moa+ day to day from one mag to another.
Wandering zero is a fairly common Hawke fault.
BTW Are you using it with a Pard 007?
The wavelength difference between natural daylight through a solo scope and an IR add-on can be 2-3 inches on the zero.
Quote from: angrybear on June 21, 2022, 11:01:03 PM
Quote from: smithy123 on June 21, 2022, 07:35:09 PM
Reply for angry bear,
Hi mate I've just put the mag back to how I had it in in the garden shooting at 20 yards and it's shooting 10/15mm to the right, yesterday it was shooting fine at 20 yards max mag and it's mil dot under but for some reason that has now change there no wind I'm shooting in the same position, bottle is at the same bar. It's bang on line with the target just 10/15mm to the right??
It's leaving me pickled this🤨🤨
That sounds to me like your scope's shagged, but as Kev says it could be canting.
Starting from basics, make sure the scope is exactly vertical on top of the rifle, I find the easiest way is to rest the bottle with the rifle at arms length, eye up the block to be vertical then look up at the scope turrets,
You'll see instantly if they're off, if they are correct the fit.
To check the scope, if possible use a rest to eliminate human error, for a target you need a cross, not a dot, so that you can align the cross of the scope which eliminates any risk of canting,
If you have 2 crosses on a target sheet, on the first fire 3 shots at minimum mag tun up to max mag shoot 3 more, move to the second cross shoot max mag first then go down to min shoot again.
In an ideal world all the shots at each target cross will be in a single group & the two should look pretty much identical.
If the min & max are in 2 different groups then the ret moved with the mag change, & to me the scope's shagged.
With regard to FFP scopes, they do cost more, you aren't going to buy a 4-16x44 (or 50) FFP for under £300,
Lots of people don't like them or don't see the point, I do but it's personal choice.
Hi mate I've just ran the test you have told me to do! I filled the 400cc alloy bottle to 240bar, on a rest so no movement. I ran the test twice and these are the results
That looks spot on Smithy, proves that the POI does NOT move if the mag changes so the scope is fine.
The other side of the coin is that it pretty much puts any error on to you, most likely it's a mix of your head position & your scope adjustment.
In reply#4 you said you're new to shooting so I'll start at the beginning with head/scope position, sorry if teaching you to suck eggs.
Close your eyes, shoulder the rifle and get in to your natural comfortable position, now open your aim eye,
If the scope is not right in front of your eye at the correct height & correct eye relief then you need to adjust it, if you have to stretch, squash or strain then you can't aim consistently.
Adjust the scope ocular (eye piece) so that the reticle is crisp & sharp to your eye, screw it all the way in, then back it out until any ghosting of the ret lines disappears.
If you have a sidewheel or AO the ranges printed on it are generalisations, adjust it to suit your eyes, so the target is crystal clear.
Hopefully once that's all done you'll have consistent accuracy.
Just noticed you say 240bar fill, even with a reg I'd say 220bar is as high as you want, even if the bottle does say 250bar SWP.
Quote from: angrybear on June 22, 2022, 08:12:58 PM
That looks spot on Smithy, proves that the POI does NOT move if the mag changes so the scope is fine.
The other side of the coin is that it pretty much puts any error on to you, most likely it's a mix of your head position & your scope adjustment.
In reply#4 you said you're new to shooting so I'll start at the beginning with head/scope position, sorry if teaching you to suck eggs.
Close your eyes, shoulder the rifle and get in to your natural comfortable position, now open your aim eye,
If the scope is not right in front of your eye at the correct height & correct eye relief then you need to adjust it, if you have to stretch, squash or strain then you can't aim consistently.
Adjust the scope ocular (eye piece) so that the reticle is crisp & sharp to your eye, screw it all the way in, then back it out until any ghosting of the ret lines disappears.
If you have a sidewheel or AO the ranges printed on it are generalisations, adjust it to suit your eyes, so the target is crystal clear.
Hopefully once that's all done you'll have consistent accuracy.
Just noticed you say 240bar fill, even with a reg I'd say 220bar is as high as you want, even if the bottle does say 250bar SWP.
I know I said I was new to shooting but I didn't mean brand new like I've been shooting for a few years just on and off but never really got deep into it until now!
I know the basics to setting the right eye relief and height and show to get the scope to zero in at let's say 25 yards in the garden. I was just confused as to how my zero could move over night.
The poi DOES change with the magnification, because the poi is 1 mil dot of hold under when zoomed in all the way, but when I take the mag down to 6 the poi is half a mil dot of hold under!!
I would say that the scope is goosed because either
a) the windage turret isn't giving equal adjustments a varying magnification and ranges. Is the windage turret close to maximum on one side?
The single range test works at 20yds but if zeroed true would it still be cock on at 50 or vice versa?
When you get the opportunity check the tracking/return to zero.
If there is enough adjustment in the scope - wind 25 clicks right, 25 up, 25 left, 25 down...should shoot back on the same zero.
b) heat expansion -something internally the erector tube assembly tightens up due to the above, maybe uneven mountings or over tightened, Could even be a bent main tube.
one zero 'hot' in the sun, gets worse as it gets hotter. Next morning the scope has cooled down and its 15mm out.
Its 3 moa which considering the close Rapid scope mounting is roughly the equivalent of a 0.06mm shim.
c) parallax is out, lenses mis-aligned due to turret issues which is why it doesn't show until you dial in at different ranges at a different mag.
See picture for parallax error
Quote from: smithy123 on June 22, 2022, 09:30:37 PM
I know I said I was new to shooting but I didn't mean brand new like I've been shooting for a few years just on and off but never really got deep into it until now!
I know the basics to setting the right eye relief and height and show to get the scope to zero in at let's say 25 yards in the garden. I was just confused as to how my zero could move over night.
The poi DOES change with the magnification, because the poi is 1 mil dot of hold under when zoomed in all the way, but when I take the mag down to 6 the poi is half a mil dot of hold under!!
NO, that is the holdover dot value that's changing, which is different to the reticle POI.
Because with an SFP scope the ret stays the same size when you change zoom, so at lower mag 1 dot is a higher value than at high mag because the picture behind the ret is smaller at low mag.
ie at 3x 1 dot might be a rabbits head but zoom in to 16x 1 dot is only the rabbits eye.
This is why an SFP scope has a "true" magnification, that is the only mag where the dot is actually 1 MOA at 100yds or 1 MRAD at 100M.
With an FFP scope the ret size changes with the mag so 1 dot is the same value at every mag.
Until you understand the basics of how the scope works aim with the centre cross & forget holdover ;)
Well I might as well throw more fuel on this fire, on this subject for FFP and SFP scopes how it works.....
The main reason for this having a 1st Focal Plane scope, The calibration of the marks on the crosshair remains the Same Through ALL Magnifications!!
No Matter if it is a MRad or Moa scope.......
So if the small tick marks are .25 moa and the Major one is 1 moa.... This never changes throughout the zoom range of the scope..
For the a 2nd Focal Plane scope, it is a bit different.....
On the Zoom ring, have noticed one of the magnification Numbers is a different color??? Usually Green in color...
Well the marking on the crosshairs are calibrated to be correct on this set magnification!!
No matter if it is an MRad or Moa scope......
Stuart
Quote from: angrybear on June 23, 2022, 12:33:30 AM
Quote from: smithy123 on June 22, 2022, 09:30:37 PM
I know I said I was new to shooting but I didn't mean brand new like I've been shooting for a few years just on and off but never really got deep into it until now!
I know the basics to setting the right eye relief and height and show to get the scope to zero in at let's say 25 yards in the garden. I was just confused as to how my zero could move over night.
The poi DOES change with the magnification, because the poi is 1 mil dot of hold under when zoomed in all the way, but when I take the mag down to 6 the poi is half a mil dot of hold under!!
NO, that is the holdover dot value that's changing, which is different to the reticle POI.
Because with an SFP scope the ret stays the same size when you change zoom, so at lower mag 1 dot is a higher value than at high mag because the picture behind the ret is smaller at low mag.
ie at 3x 1 dot might be a rabbits head but zoom in to 16x 1 dot is only the rabbits eye.
This is why an SFP scope has a "true" magnification, that is the only mag where the dot is actually 1 MOA at 100yds or 1 MRAD at 100M.
With an FFP scope the ret size changes with the mag so 1 dot is the same value at every mag.
Until you understand the basics of how the scope works aim with the centre cross & forget holdover ;)
Using the centre cross isn't going to get me anywhere in the field apart from a lot of missed rabbit I would only be able to take shots at the set zero range I wouldn't be to get closer or take them longer shots, how do I take a 70 yard shot whilst aiming on the centre hairs when zerod in for 50 yards.
And that's what I was ment to say the holdover dot value changes, I'll not get anywhere just sticking to the centre I have to learn at some point. What I don't understand is the working the clicks out and converting them, I keep it simple in my head I shoot the target and move the clickers accordingly, its worked fine for me
This thread is getting out of hand now! My brain is overloaded with bits what everyone is throwing in, what I think I'm gunna do is take a step back and try learn it on my own because I need it broke down into simple terms, You lot are confusing the crap out of me🤨🤨
simple.. you're getting lateral shift in point of impact with changing magnification and range.?
comes, goes- different every time?
that's lens alignment error..damned good reason for a new scope
Smithy.. is this FAC?
you're talking 50-70yds.
One of the reasons why I couldn't get on with SFP mildots was because dots just didn't coincide with FAC trajectories.
Mils work for sub-12 to 50 but with FAC 50- 70yds there's only 1 dot drop @10x or guess work.
Shouldn't need to use the dots with a rangefinder.. zero cock-on at one range and remember the holdover for 55,60,65,70.. rabbits ear, half ear.
Worst case is you cut the throat every now and then and they flop around for a bit.
Only problem is hares.. bigger ears ;D
Quote from: smithy123 on June 23, 2022, 07:35:57 AM
This thread is getting out of hand now! My brain is overloaded with bits what everyone is throwing in, what I think I'm gunna do is take a step back and try learn it on my own because I need it broke down into simple terms, You lot are confusing the crap out of me🤨🤨
OK, a final practical demonstration on paper, neither rifle is actually zero'd at 25yds but that's my set out range.
At each mag setting I took 1 shot at the lower target with the centre cross & then 1 shot with 1 mil holdover, at the mag setting stated under the target,
I will admit that at 4x with the FFP the target was hard to align with the ultra fine cross but it's not an issue in the field because there are no exact crosses in nature ;)
See how with the SFP scope 1 dot of holdover changes from 51mm at 3x, to 19mm at 10x while the centre cross, personal inaccuracy apart, remains fixed,
had the range to target changed the value of the holdover would also change, at 50yds 3x would be 102mm, 10x 38mm
With the FFP scope the value of 1 dot remains steady across magnification, but will also change with range, double the range double the holdover value.
This is why shooting holdover with a SFP scope requires lots of maths to be accurate.
Smithy do you have Hawke Chairgun trajectory program ? If not download it, it's free & still probably the easiest to understand.
PS MS Edge will not download chairgun because it uses java & edge doesn't support java, you need to use settings to download it in OE or use another browser.
1st focal plane makes thing very EZ!!!!
By knowing your Range, you know how much to hold over/under depending on your TRAJECTORY!!
So with a FFP, you know how many dots/hash marks to hold over/under no matter the magnification!
Remember you are not shooting a LASER Beam!!
The Trajectory is an ARC.....
Here is a little diagram to help explain this.....
(https://photos.imageevent.com/scl_electronics/gun/air/websize/bulletfight_1_.jpg)
What is important is Knowing the Trajectory of your Rapid and Pellet combo!!
This can be done by a fancy program or phone app.
Or by pencil and paper, jotting down the poi at various ranges...
So in the field, the most useful tool is a good LASER Rangefinder!!!!!
This another layer that is just too much to add to this post...
Maybe at a later date!
Stuart
Quote from: smithy123 on June 22, 2022, 10:44:11 AM
Quote from: KevG on June 21, 2022, 09:10:05 PM
your not canting the gun are you.
KevG
What is canting Kev mate
Canting is when you do not hold the rifle vertical in the aim,
If the rifle (& therefore scope) are held at an angle, any adjustment to the turrets will move the POI along that angle.
Think clockface, the clicks move the POI along the arms from the centre out, if the scope cross is pointing 12-6 & 3-9 the clicks send the POI either vertical or horizontal,
but if the cross is pointing, say 1-7 & 10-4, the clicks move the POI in both planes.